Learning to suspend implicated contrast
Open Access
- 23 November 2017
- journal article
- Published by John Benjamins Publishing Company in Linguistics in the Netherlands 1997
- Vol. 34, 143-155
- https://doi.org/10.1075/avt.34.10wol
Abstract
Children acquire the meaning of ook ‘also’ in Dutch relatively late (Bergsma 2006), although this focus particle is highly frequent. We argue that this late acquisition is caused by a pragmatic rule: contrastive implicature. We follow Sæbø (2004), who argues that additives are used because without them, the sentences they appear in would be interpreted as contrastive in relation to the context. Data from a sentence completion task administered to Dutch L1 learners (N = 62, ages 4;0–5;11) show that, on average, four-year-olds do not distinguish sentences with ook from sentences without ook. Five-year-olds do better on sentences with ook but worse on sentences without it. We argue that they have generally acquired contrastive implicature: they apply the correct contrastive interpretation to sentences without ook, but overgeneralize this implicature to sentences with ook, before completely acquiring the meaning of ook.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Additive Particles in Romance and Germanic Languages: Are They Really Similar?Linguistik Online, 2015
- Fitting Linear Mixed-Effects Models Usinglme4Journal of Statistical Software, 2015
- Language Acquisition and the Functional Category SystemPublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,2012
- Restrictions on addition: children's interpretation of the focus particles auch ‘also’ and nur ‘only’ in GermanJournal of Child Language, 2011
- (Un)Stressed ook in Child DutchPublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,2006
- Acquisition of focus marking in European PortuguesePublished by John Benjamins Publishing Company ,2006
- Conversational Contrast and Conventional Parallel: Topic Implicatures and Additive PresuppositionsJournal of Semantics, 2004
- Auch and noch in Child and Adult GermanPublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,2003
- The Meaning of Focus ParticlesPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2002