Γameσσetai/γe Maσσetai: HomerIliad9.394 and the Constitutive Role of Irregularity
- 14 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Hellenic Studies
- Vol. 141, 224-240
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0075426921000112
Abstract
This paper uses a textual decision atIliad9.394 to argue for irregularity as a functional and meaningful principle in the constitution of the Homeric text. In contrast to almost all recent major editions, I argue that the ‘irregular’ MSS γαμέσσεται should be preferred to the Aristarchaean conjecture γε μάσσεται. Aristarchus’ widely adopted emendation, I suggest, is the product of a drive towards standardization that is still operative in Homeric text-critical practice. This paper opposes that standardization with the evidence of ancient, perhaps pre-Alexandrian, responses toIliad9.394, in which the ‘irregularity’ of γαμέσσεται is embraced as an interpretive opportunity. The formal disruptions of γαμέσσεται, I propose, can be understood by locating them both within the immediate context ofIliad9 and within the wider thematics of irregularity that mark the character of Achilles. This paper thus attempts to reframe our approach to the role of irregularity in theIliadas an integral feature of meaning rather than grounds for suspecting the integrity of the text.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rape and the Politics of Consent in Classical AthensPhoenix, 2004
- WEST’s IliadThe Classical Review, 2000
- The Homeric poems as oral dictated textsThe Classical Quarterly, 1998
- Homer’s MeterPublished by Brill ,1997
- The "Iliad" and Its Editors: Dictation and RedactionClassical Antiquity, 1990
- Homeric Words and SpeakersThe Journal of Hellenic Studies, 1986
- The Language of Achilles: Construction vs. RepresentationClassical World, 1986
- The Proem of the Iliad: Homer's ArtClassical Philology, 1979
- Speech as a Personality Symbol: The Case of AchillesLanguage, 1978
- The Language of AchillesThe Classical Quarterly, 1973