A Comparative Study of Accident Risk Related to Speech-Based and Handheld Texting during a Sudden Braking Event in Urban Road Environments
Open Access
- 6 August 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 17 (16), 5675
- https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17165675
Abstract
The use of mobile phones while driving is a very common phenomenon that has become one of the main causes of traffic accidents. Many studies on the effects of mobile phone use on accident risk have focused on conversation and texting; however, few studies have directly compared the impacts of speech-based texting and handheld texting on accident risk, especially during sudden braking events. This study aims to statistically model and quantify the effects of potential factors on accident risk associated with a sudden braking event in terms of the driving behavior characteristics of young drivers, the behavior of the lead vehicle (LV), and mobile phone distraction tasks (i.e., both speech-based and handheld texting). For this purpose, a total of fifty-five licensed young drivers completed a driving simulator experiment in a Chinese urban road environment under five driving conditions: baseline (no phone use), simple speech-based texting, complex speech-based texting, simple handheld texting, and complex handheld texting. Generalized linear mixed models were developed for the brake reaction time and rear-end accident probability during the sudden braking events. The results showed that handheld texting tasks led to a delayed response to the sudden braking events as compared to the baseline. However, speech-based texting tasks did not slow down the response. Moreover, drivers responded faster when the initial time headway was shorter, when the initial speed was higher, or when the LV deceleration rate was greater. The rear-end accident probability respectively increased by 2.41 and 2.77 times in the presence of simple and complex handheld texting while driving. Surprisingly, the effects of speech-based texting tasks were not significant, but the accident risk increased if drivers drove the vehicle with a shorter initial time headway or a higher LV deceleration rate. In summary, these findings suggest that the effects of mobile phone distraction tasks, driving behavior characteristics, and the behavior of the LV should be taken into consideration when developing algorithms for forward collision warning systems.Funding Information
- the national key Research and Development Program of China (2019YFB1600500)
- The National Natural Science Foundation of China (51775053)
- the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (CHD 300102220202)
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Performance Degradation During Sudden Hazardous Events: A Comparative Analysis of Use of a Phone and a Music Player During DrivingIEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 2018
- Getting away with texting: Behavioural adaptation of drivers engaging in visual-manual tasks while drivingTransportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2018
- The impact of speech-based texting on drivers' braking reaction and deceleration duration in the car-following scenarioJournal of Transportation Safety & Security, 2018
- A rear-end collision risk assessment model based on drivers’ collision avoidance process under influences of cell phone use and gender—A driving simulator based studyAccident Analysis & Prevention, 2016
- Investigating driver reaction time and speed during mobile phone conversations with a lead vehicle in front: A driving simulator comprehensive studyJournal of Transportation Safety & Security, 2016
- Drivers’ rear end collision avoidance behaviors under different levels of situational urgencyTransportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 2016
- Analysis of factors affecting drivers’ choice to engage with a mobile phone while driving in BeijingTransportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, 2016
- Texting while driving: Is speech-based text entry less risky than handheld text entry?Accident Analysis & Prevention, 2014
- Impact of texting on young drivers' behavior and safety on urban and rural roads through a simulation experimentJournal of Safety Research, 2014
- Text Messaging During Simulated DrivingHuman Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 2009