Out of sight, out of mind: a prospective observational study to estimate the duration of the Hawthorne effect on hand hygiene events
- 1 November 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Quality & Safety
- Vol. 29 (11), 932-938
- https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2019-010310
Abstract
Background Human auditing has been the gold standard for evaluating hand hygiene (HH) compliance but is subject to the Hawthorne effect (HE), the change in subjects' behaviour due to their awareness of being observed. For the first time, we used electronic HH monitoring to characterise the duration of the HE on HH events after human auditors have left the ward. Methods Observations were prospectively conducted on two transplant wards at a tertiary centre between May 2018 and January 2019. HH events were measured using the electronic GOJO Smartlink Activity Monitoring System located throughout the ward. Non-covert human auditing was conducted in 1-hour intervals at random locations on both wards on varying days of the week. Two adjusted negative binomial regression models were fit in order to estimate an overall auditor effect and a graded auditor effect. Results In total, 365 674 HH dispensing events were observed out of a possible 911 791 opportunities. In the adjusted model, the presence of an auditor increased electronic HH events by approximately 2.5-fold in the room closest to where the auditor was standing (9.86 events per hour/3.98 events per hour; p<0.01), an effect sustained across only the partial hour before and after the auditor was present but not beyond the first hour after the auditor left. This effect persisted but was attenuated in areas distal from the auditor (total ward events of 6.91*6.32-7.55, p<0.01). Additionally, there was significant variability in the magnitude of the HE based on temporal and geographic distribution of audits. Conclusion The HE on HH events appears to last for a limited time on inpatient wards and is highly dynamic across time and auditor location. These findings further challenge the validity and value of human auditing and support the need for alternative and complementary monitoring methods.This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hand hygiene compliance in transplant and other special patient groups: An observational studyAmerican Journal of Infection Control, 2013
- Compliance of Health Care Workers with Hand Hygiene Practices: Independent Advantages of Overt and Covert ObserversPLOS ONE, 2013
- Monitoring Hand Hygiene via Human Observers: How Should We Be Sampling?Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 2012
- Practically speaking: Rethinking hand hygiene improvement programs in health care settingsAmerican Journal of Infection Control, 2011
- Impact of observation and analysis methodology when reporting hand hygiene dataJournal of Hospital Infection, 2011
- The World Health Organization hand hygiene observation methodAmerican Journal of Infection Control, 2009
- Compliance with hand hygiene on surgical, medical, and neurologic intensive care units: Direct observation versus calculated disinfectant usageAmerican Journal of Infection Control, 2009
- Variability in the Hawthorne Effect With Regard to Hand Hygiene Performance in High- and Low-Performing Inpatient Care UnitsInfection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 2009
- The Hawthorne Effect: a randomised, controlled trialBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2007
- Compliance With Antiseptic Hand Rub Use in Intensive Care Units The Hawthorne EffectInfection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 2006