Unpacking the Complexity of Gender Integration in the U.S. Military Using Discourse Analysis: The Case of Servicewomen’s Talk Around Having to Prove Themselves
Open Access
- 1 December 2021
- journal article
- Published by Adam Mickiewicz University Poznan in STAP
- Vol. 56 (s1), 551-557
- https://doi.org/10.2478/stap-2021-0012
Abstract
A quasi-idiomatic expression ‘women have to prove themselves’ reflects various performance pressures and heightened visibility of women functioning in gendered professional spaces as advocated by tokenism theory. It is an example of how discriminatory practice – according to which competent and qualified women entering the culturally masculine professions are explicitly and implicitly expected to work harder for any recognition – gets discoursed in language and becomes a “rhetorically powerful form of talk” (Kitzinger 2000: 124). This paper explores the question: what is it that U.S. servicewomen functioning in the culturally hypermasculine space need to do to prove themselves? To this end, qualitative semi-structured interviews with women veterans of the recent Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts are qualitatively scrutinized with the methods of discourse analysis and conversation analysis to 1) identify practices that U.S. servicewomen engage in to symbolically (re-)claim their place and status in the military, i.e., to prove they belong; 2) find out how the talk around proving emerged in the course of the conversation and how it was further interactionally sustained and/or dealt with in talk-in-interaction. The findings of the micro-level analysis – interpreted through the lenses of tokenism and the category of the ‘honorary man’ – reveal women’s complex and nuanced struggle to fit and find acceptance in the military culture of hypermasculinity. They also re-engage with the ideas of tokenism by demonstrating that various acts of proving, reflecting women’s token status, may concurrently and paradoxically be a means to earn honorary man status.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Women fighters and the ‘beautiful soul’ narrativeInternational Review of the Red Cross, 2010
- ‘I’m not gonna hit a lady’: Conversation analysis, membership categorization and men’s denials of violence towards womenDiscourse & Society, 2010
- Feminism and Military Gender Practices: Israeli Women Soldiers in “Masculine” RolesSociological Inquiry, 2003
- 2001 Division 35 Presidential Address: Context Matters: Understanding Tokenism Processes and Their Impact on Women's WorkPsychology of Women Quarterly, 2002
- How to Resist an IdiomResearch on Language and Social Interaction, 2000
- RETHINKING TOKENISM:Gender & Society, 1991
- African American Women in the U.S. MilitaryArmed Forces & Society, 1991
- Adapting to a man's world: United States air force Female OfficersDefense Analysis, 1991
- Complainable Matters: The Use of Idiomatic Expressions in Making ComplaintsSocial Problems, 1988
- Some Effects of Proportions on Group Life: Skewed Sex Ratios and Responses to Token WomenAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1977