Teaching clinical reasoning to undergraduate medical students by illness script method: a randomized controlled trial
Open Access
- 2 February 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 21 (1), 1-7
- https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-021-02522-0
Abstract
The illness script method employs a theoretical outline (e.g., epidemiology, pathophysiology, signs and symptoms, diagnostic tests, interventions) to clarify how clinicians organized medical knowledge for clinical reasoning in the diagnosis domain. We hypothesized that an educational intervention based on the illness script method would improve medical students’ clinical reasoning skills in the diagnosis domain. This study is a randomized controlled trial involving 100 fourth-year medical students in Shiraz Medical School, Iran. Fifty students were randomized to the intervention group, who were taught clinical reasoning skills based on the illness script method for three diseases during one clinical scenario. Another 50 students were randomized to the control group, who were taught the clinical presentation based on signs and symptoms of the same three diseases as the intervention group. The outcomes of interest were learner satisfaction with the intervention and posttest scores on both an internally developed knowledge test and a Script Concordance Test (SCT). Of the hundred participating fourth-year medical students, 47 (47%) were male, and 53 (53%) were female. On the knowledge test, there was no difference in pretest scores between the intervention and control group, which suggested a similar baseline knowledge in both groups; however, posttest scores in the intervention group were (15.74 ± 2.47 out of 20) statistically significantly higher than the control group (14.38 ± 2.59 out of 20, P = 0.009). On the SCT, the mean score for the intervention group (6.12 ± 1.95 out of 10) was significantly higher than the control group (4.54 ± 1.56 out of 10; P = 0.0001). Learner satisfaction data indicated that the intervention was well-received by students. Teaching with the illness script method was an effective way to improve students’ clinical reasoning skills in the diagnosis domain suggested by posttest and SCT scores for specific clinical scenarios. Whether this approach translates to improved generalized clinical reasoning skills in real clinical settings merits further study.This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- The validity and reliability of script concordance test in otolaryngology residency training2016
- Can Think Aloud Be Used to Teach and Assess Clinical Reasoning in Graduate Medical Education?Journal of Graduate Medical Education, 2015
- Thirty years of illness scripts: Theoretical origins and practical applicationsMedical Teacher, 2014
- Script concordance testing: From theory to practice: AMEE Guide No. 75Medical Teacher, 2013
- Diagnostic Reasoning: Where We've Been, Where We’re GoingTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2013
- An innovative method to assess clinical reasoning skills: Clinical reasoning tests in the second national medical science Olympiad in IranBMC Research Notes, 2011
- Script Concordance Tests: Guidelines for ConstructionBMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 2008
- Educational Strategies to Promote Clinical Diagnostic ReasoningThe New England Journal of Medicine, 2006
- What every teacher needs to know about clinical reasoningMedical Education, 2005
- How can we test clinical reasoning?The Lancet, 1995