Contagious is around: about some aspects of incorrect methodology and terminology in soil research and publications
Open Access
- 1 June 2020
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Soil Science and Agrochemistry of the Siberian Branch in Почвы и окружающая среда
- Vol. 3 (1), e109
- https://doi.org/10.31251/pos.v3i1.109
Abstract
The article discusses some examples of incorrect methodology and terminology practice in soil research and publications. In particular, the authors draw attention to extremely inflated and unjustified use of the phrase “statistically significant”, to the controversy between the chemical determination and terminological definition of soil humus, to the inadequacy of using mass concentrations of chemical elements to inferring soil organic matter stoichiometry, to frequent interpreting empirical regression as if describing some conceptual relationship, to the principle impossibility to estimate bacteria and fungi numbers in soil by agar plate counts of colony-forming units. Based on the discussed examples, the authors conclude that the ease and the rate of the present-day communication flow will increasingly enhance the role of communication exchange in estimating the validity of results of a certain piece of scientific cognition, which will significantly increase the negative impact of consensuality, especially in soil science, as soil is one of the most complex natural bodies.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparative Characteristics of Recent and Buried Soil Associations in the Desert-Steppe Zone on the Volga-Don InterfluveEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Effect of Long-Term Application of Organic and Mineral Fertilizers on the Organic Carbon Content and Nitrogen Regime of Soddy-Podzolic SoilEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Formal Criteria for the Humus Status of Mountainous Peat Soils in Altitudinal ZonesEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Scientific truth: consensual-expert natureHumanities Bulletin of BMSTU, 2019
- Nonhydrolyzable Part of Soil Organic Matter in Buried and Modern SoilsEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Effect of Nonylphenols on the Abundance and Taxonomic Structure of the Soil Microbial CommunityEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Transformation of Nitrogen Compounds in Soils of Mountain Tundra Ecosystems in the KhibinyEurasian Soil Science, 2019
- The Influence of Ground Fires on the Properties and Erosion of Forest Soils in the Southern Urals (Bashkir State Nature Reserve)Eurasian Soil Science, 2019
- Влияние посевов растений-сидератов на динамику численности микроорганизмов основных эколого-трофических групп в почве виноградникаMagarach Vinogradstvo i Vinodelie, 2019
- METHODS FOR MEASURING BIOMASS OF SOIL MICROORGANISMSRussian Journal of Ecosystem Ecology, 2018