Public Perceptions of Moral Insanity in the 19th Century
- 1 September 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health) in Journal of Nervous & Mental Disease
- Vol. 207 (9), 805-814
- https://doi.org/10.1097/nmd.0000000000001035
Abstract
The diagnosis of moral insanity was primarily used through the best part of the 19th century to define and justify the psychiatric treatment of a particular type of conduct in which the patient seemed otherwise rational but displayed certain inexplicable and undesirable behaviors deemed socially perverse or “unfit.” This article traces the history of this highly contested concept, which mirrors a historical arc in which psychiatry emerges as a discipline and stakes territorial claims on defining and regulating moral behavior. As illustration, I focus on the Hinchman Conspiracy Trial of 1849 as a less known case of wrongful confinement that hinged on proving the diagnosis of moral insanity in court. Moral insanity is a case study of the efforts to medicalize human ethical conduct, an effort starkly resisted by both the courts and the public. Some of the legacies of the term are the contemporary use of insanity as a legal defense, and the ability of patients to dispute psychiatric ward confinement orders in court.This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moral insanity and psychological disorder: the hybrid roots of psychiatryHistory of Psychiatry, 2017
- The emergence and development of psychopathyHistory of the Human Sciences, 2014
- Davis, Inc.: The Business of Asylum Reform in the Periodical PressAmerican Periodicals: A Journal of History & Criticism, 2010
- THE UNREPENTANT HORSE‐SLASHER: MORAL INSANITY AND THE ORIGINS OF CRIMINOLOGICAL THOUGHT*Criminology, 2004
- From sinners to degenerates: the medicalization of morality in the 19th centuryHistory of the Human Sciences, 2002
- Moral insanity, science and religion in nineteenth-century America: the Gray-Ray debateHistory of Psychiatry, 1996
- J C Prichard's concept of moral insanity—a medical theory of the corruption of human natureMedical History, 1996
- The evolution of commitment law in the nineteenth century: A reinterpretation.Law and Human Behavior, 1982
- Friends Asylum, Morgan Hinchman, and Moral InsanityQuaker History, 1978