An augmented reality study for public participation in urban planning
Open Access
- 12 June 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Journal of Location Based Services
- Vol. 17 (1), 48-77
- https://doi.org/10.1080/17489725.2022.2086309
Abstract
Ongoing urbanisation processes invoke immense construction activities, for which citizens often participate in planning. Yet, imagining planned buildings based on visual representations is a highly demanding task. While traditional methods, such as construction spans, 2D, or 3D visualisation often fail to offer a complete picture, we propose Augmented Reality (AR) as a more adequate tool. We first present an evaluation of the suitability of AR compared to construction spans for a future building and assess which degree of abstraction of AR is most effective, as well as difficulty of interpreting them correctly. In a between-subjects field study we compare construction spans and a prototype AR application including three levels of detail (LOD) of the same building project. Participants solve two estimation tasks using the construction spans and six estimation tasks using the AR application, before answering a questionnaire on the different visualisation methods. We find participants are confident about the potential of AR, but no significant differences between the different LOD groups in subjective assessment. Results suggest that previous knowledge (e.g. in GIS) may have a positive impact on dimension estimation performance. Also, details, such as façade elements or windows, could facilitate estimation tasks because they allow inferences about a building’s size.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Current status, opportunities and challenges of augmented reality in educationComputers & Education, 2013
- Citizen engagement and urban change: Three case studies of material deliberationCities, 2012
- How does presentation method and measurement protocol affect distance estimation in real and virtual environments?ACM Transactions on Applied Perception, 2010
- Gradual transitions and their effects on presence and distance estimationComputers & Graphics, 2010
- The Second Life of urban planning? Using NeoGeography tools for community engagementJournal of Location Based Services, 2009
- Design and Evaluation of a Real-World Virtual Environment for Architecture and Urban PlanningPRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality, 2007
- The effect of feedback training on distance estimation in virtual environmentsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2005
- GIS-based visualisation of rural landscapes: defining ‘sufficient’ realism for environmental decision-makingLandscape and Urban Planning, 2003
- Urban visualization and public inquiries: the case of the Heron Tower, Londonarq: Architectural Research Quarterly, 2002
- A touring machine: Prototyping 3D mobile augmented reality systems for exploring the urban environmentPersonal and Ubiquitous Computing, 1997