“These and Those Are the Words of the Living God, but …”: Meaning, Background, and Reception of an Early Rabbinic Teaching
- 23 August 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in AJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies
- Vol. 45 (2), 382-410
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0364009421000064
Abstract
This is the first article-length treatment of the famous rabbinic dictum “These and those are the words of the living God, but the Law always follows Beit Hillel.” The statement's significance lies in the innovative manner in which it negotiates the monistic and pluralistic tendencies within the rabbinic tradition. “These and those …” first emerged in the late tannaitic or early amoraic period as a reworking of an earlier Tosefta text. The Yerushalmi, consistent with its overall monistic tendencies, cited this text only for its ruling in favor of Beit Hillel, marginalizing its affirmation that the teachings of Beit Shammai represent “the words of the living God.” The Bavli embraced both the pluralistic and monistic stances of “These and those …” and further placed the declaration in a wider narrative context, imbuing it with social and ethical significance.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- “A Heart of Many Chambers”: The Theological Hermeneutics of Legal MultivocalityHarvard Theological Review, 2015
- Response to Azzan Yadin-Israel on Rabbinic Polysemy: Do They “Preach” What They Practice?AJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies, 2014
- Rabbinic Polysemy: A Response to Steven FraadeAJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies, 2014
- Rabbinic Polysemy and Pluralism Revisited: Between Praxis and ThematizationAJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies, 2007
- Jeremiah 21-36: A New Translation with Introduction and CommentaryJournal of Biblical Literature, 2005
- Border LinesPublished by University of Pennsylvania Press ,2004
- Rational Rabbis: Science and Talmudic CultureJewish Quarterly Review, 1998
- In Pursuit of the Counter-Text: The Turn to the Jewish Legal Model in Contemporary American Legal TheoryHarvard Law Review, 1993
- Obligation: A Jewish Jurisprudence of the Social OrderJournal of Law and Religion, 1987
- The Supreme Court, 1982 TermHarvard Law Review, 1983