Divergent Realities Across the Digital–Material Divide
Open Access
- 21 November 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in Law, Technology and Humans
- Vol. 2 (2), 53-68
- https://doi.org/10.5204/lthj.1483
Abstract
This article utilises the example of Australia’s social welfare agency ‘Centrelink’ and its Online Compliance Intervention (OCI) program to illustrate the process of digital translation and digital determinations of material reality. The article explains the digital translation process through the adaptation of various aspects of Charles Sanders Peirce’s philosophy such as the triadic sign model, signification, fallibilism and synechism. Semiotics, or the ‘study of meaning making’, highlights the subjective nature of data analysis. A semiotic approach not only explains the differing realities of digital and material space and the lack of distinction between digital and material phenomena, but also provides further insight into algorithmic determinations of reality and the inherent limitations on our knowledge of digital or material reality. The same data can produce divergent realities within digital space and between the material and digital spaces. The article concludes that the design of algorithms, the nature of their representations and the outcomes they generate lack the complexity and nuance of reality, and disregards social influences on meaning and interpretation. As illustrated by the real-life failure of Centrelink’s OCI, this article warns against interpreting the digital as an accurate rendering of the real.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- The return of the social: Algorithmic identity in an age of symbolic demiseNew Media & Society, 2020
- Exclusion by design: intersections of social, digital and data exclusionInformation, Communication & Society, 2019
- When data is capital: Datafication, accumulation, and extractionBig Data & Society, 2019
- Of algorithms, Apps and advice: digital social policy and service deliveryJournal of Asian Public Policy, 2018
- The art of deciding with data: evidence from how employers translate credit reports into hiring decisionsSocio-Economic Review, 2017
- Heuristics of the algorithm: Big Data, user interpretation and institutional translationBig Data & Society, 2015
- Successful failure: what Foucault can teach us about privacy self-management in a world of Facebook and big dataEthics and Information Technology, 2015
- Recommended for you: The Netflix Prize and the production of algorithmic cultureNew Media & Society, 2014
- Models as icons: modeling models in the semiotic framework of Peirce’s theory of signsSynthese, 2012