References to jurisprudence of foreign constitutional courts in judgments and decisions of the Constitutional Tribunal of the Republic of Poland
Open Access
- 30 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II in Review of European and Comparative Law
- Vol. 49 (2), 71-96
- https://doi.org/10.31743/recl.13207
Abstract
In its jurisprudence, the Constitutional Tribunal of the Republic of Poland often uses the comparative law method. For it, the comparative material is not only the normative acts in force in other countries, but also foreign jurisprudence. The article presents the results of a quantitative and qualitative study of the judgments of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal in terms of the presence of references to the judgments of other constitutional courts. Reference by the Tribunal to foreign constitutional jurisprudence is a relatively rare practice, but not an occasional one. It was intensified after Poland's accession to the European Union. Although the main point of reference for the Tribunal in its comparative analysis is still the jurisprudence of the German Federal Constitutional Court and constitutional courts of other Western countries, it also increasingly frequently reaches to the judgments of the constitutional courts of Central European and Baltic countries. The subject issue is part of the progressive process of the so-called transnational judicial discourse or judicial globalization. The reluctance of the Tribunal to reach in its rulings to judgments of foreign constitutional courts, which has been observed since 2017, may be the beginning of its assumption of an exceptionalistic attitude similar to the U.S. Supreme Court. In its jurisprudence, the Constitutional Tribunal of the Republic of Poland often uses the comparative law method. For it, comparative material is not only the normative acts in force in other countries, but also foreign jurisprudence. This article presents the results of a quantitative and qualitative study of the judgments of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal in terms of the presence of references to the judgments of other constitutional courts. Reference by the Tribunal to foreign constitutional jurisprudence is a relatively rare practice, but not an occasional one. It was intensified after Poland’s accession to the European Union. Although the main point of reference for the Tribunal in its comparative analysis is still the jurisprudence of the German Federal Constitutional Court and constitutional courts of other Western countries, it also increasingly frequently reaches to the judgments of the constitutional courts of Central European and Baltic countries. The subject issue is part of the progressive process of the so-called transnational judicial discourse or judicial globalization. The reluctance of the Tribunal to reach in its rulings to judgments of foreign constitutional courts, which has been observed since 2017, may be the beginning of its assumption of an exceptionalistic attitude similar to the U.S. Supreme Court.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- What Makes for More or Less Powerful Constitutional Courts?SSRN Electronic Journal, 2017
- The Transnational Judicial Dialogue of the Supreme Court of Canada: The Primary Mechanisms and Main EffectsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2017
- Is it Legitimate and Beneficial for Judges to Compare?Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) ,2015
- Transnational Judicial Dialogue as an Organisational FieldEuropean Law Journal, 2013
- Language, Legal Origins, and Culture Before the Courts: Cross-Citations Between Supreme Courts in EuropeSupreme Court Economic Review, 2013
- Reference to Foreign Law in the Supreme Courts of Britain and the Netherlands: Explaining the Development of Judicial PracticesUtrecht Law Review, 2012
- The European Court of Human Rights as a ‘Constitutional Court’: Definitional Debates and the Dynamics of ReformPublished by Oxford University Press (OUP) ,2007
- 'A Shining City on a Hill': American Exceptionalism and the Supreme Court's Practice of Relying on Foreign LawSSRN Electronic Journal, 2006
- Luis Lopez Guerra Former judge, Tribunal Constitutional (Constitutional Court) SpainInternational Journal of Constitutional Law, 2005
- The Impact of the German Federal Constitutional Court on Politics and Policy OutputGovernment and Opposition, 1985