When academic achievement (also) reflects personality: Using the personality-achievement saturation hypothesis (PASH) to explain differential associations between achievement measures and personality traits.
- 1 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 114 (2), 326-345
- https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000571
Abstract
Students' academic achievement is a key predictor of various life outcomes and is commonly used for selection as well as for educational monitoring and accountability. With regard to achievement indicators, a differentiation has traditionally been drawn between grades and standardized tests. There is initial, albeit inconclusive, evidence that these indicators might differentially reflect students' personality as encapsulated in the Big Five personality traits as well as measures of cognitive abilities. In this article, we propose the personality-achievement saturation hypothesis (PASH) as an overarching model that describes the association between achievement indicators and personality. The PASH suggests that the differentiation between grades and tests is too simplistic and that associations between personality and achievement instead vary across five main features of the achievement measures that are used: level of standardization, relevance for the student, curricular validity, instructional sensitivity, and cognitive ability saturation. On the basis of findings from prior studies, we focused in particular on conscientiousness and openness to test the PASH. We used data from three large-scale studies (total N = 14,953) and aggregated our findings across these studies. In line with the PASH, the Big Five trait of conscientiousness was most strongly related to measures that were less standardized and less saturated with cognitive ability but higher on curriculum validity, relevance, and instructional sensitivity. In addition, openness was most strongly related to measures that were higher on standardization and cognitive ability saturation but lower on relevance, curriculum validity, and instructional sensitivity in English. Educational Impact and Implications Statement Achievement measures are of central importance for student selection, employment, and educational policy, and according to a widely shared belief, they involve intellectual abilities as well as aspects of personality such as effort and persistence. Up to now, prior research has remained rather inconclusive about why achievement measures vary in their degree of personality saturation. In this study, we developed and successfully tested a new framework (the PASH), which categorizes achievement measures along five main features and thereby contributes to a better explanation of differential associations between personality traits and different achievement measures.Keywords
Funding Information
- state government of Baden-Württemberg
- state government of Hamburg
- Baden-Württemberg Ministry of Science, Research, and the Arts
- European Social Fund
- Ministry of Science, Research, and the Arts of Baden-Württemberg
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Meritocracy and theGaokao: a survey study of higher education selection and socio-economic participation in East ChinaBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 2013
- The value of suppressor effects in explicating the construct validity of symptom measures.Psychological Assessment, 2013
- Openness, fluid intelligence, and crystallized intelligence: Toward an integrative modelJournal of Research in Personality, 2012
- What's in a grade? The multidimensional nature of what teacher-assigned grades assess in high schoolEducational Research and Evaluation, 2011
- A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysisResearch Synthesis Methods, 2010
- Reconsidering grades as data for decision making: more than just academic knowledgeJournal of Educational Administration, 2009
- Undermining quality teaching and learningTheory and Research in Education, 2009
- Personality and career success: Concurrent and longitudinal relationsEuropean Journal of Personality, 2009
- Missing Data Analysis: Making It Work in the Real WorldAnnual Review of Psychology, 2009
- Test-Taking Motivation and Mathematics Performance in TIMSS 2003International Journal of Testing, 2007