Getting Proportionality in Perspective: Philosophy, History, and Institutions
- 1 December 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Chicago Press in Crime and Justice
- Vol. 50 (1), 77-114
- https://doi.org/10.1086/715030
Abstract
Conceptual debates about proportionality and its moral and political force need to be placed in historical and institutional context. Conceptual, moral, political, and practical questions about proportionality are inextricably linked. This insight should lead us away from the dominant conception of proportionality as a moral precept and toward a political conception of proportionality that is inevitably shaped by prevailing conceptions of what proportionality is for and, in modern democracies, is grounded in democratic practices and the institutional structures of democratic states. This insight has important implications for the prevailing disciplinary division of labor, calling into question the tendency to separate conceptual and philosophical from social theories of punishment. It is important to try to understand the conditions under which stable constraints on the state’s power to punish, and accountability mechanisms adequate to guaranteeing the fittingness of punishment by reference to democratically endorsed standards—which seem to be the key animating concerns of contemporary appeals to proportionality—are most likely to be realized, and conversely where they are likely to be most under threat. This is both an important issue in itself, and a case study in the interaction between concept and context.This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding the Determinants of Penal Policy: Crime, Culture, and Comparative Political EconomyAnnual Review of Criminology, 2018
- Prisons, Proportionality and Recent Penal HistoryThe Modern Law Review, 2017
- The Metaphor of ProportionalityJournal of Law and Society, 2016
- What is the Criminal Law for?Law and Philosophy, 2015
- Crime, punishment and segregation in the United States: The paradox of local democracyPunishment & Society, 2015
- To Blame or to Forgive? Reconciling Punishment and Forgiveness in Criminal JusticeOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 2015
- The Chimera of Proportionality: Institutionalising Limits on Punishment in Contemporary Social and Political SystemsThe Modern Law Review, 2015
- Nordic Exceptionalism revisited: Explaining the paradox of a Janus-faced penal regimeTheoretical Criminology, 2012
- From the Consulting Room to the Court Room? Taking the Clinical Model of Responsibility Without Blame into the Legal RealmOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 2012
- Reentry as a rite of passagePunishment & Society, 2011