Challenges in Designing and Delivering Diets and Assessing Adherence: A Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluating the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans
Open Access
- 13 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Elsevier BV in Current Developments in Nutrition
- Vol. 4 (3), nzaa022
- https://doi.org/10.1093/cdn/nzaa022
Abstract
Controlled-feeding trials are challenging to design and administer in a free-living setting. There is a need to share methods and best practices for diet design, delivery, and standard adherence metrics. This report describes menu planning, implementing, and monitoring of controlled diets for an 8-wk free-living trial comparing a diet pattern based on the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) and a more typical American diet (TAD) pattern based on NHANES 2009–2010. The objectives were to 1) provide meals that were acceptable, portable, and simple to assemble at home; 2) blind the intervention diets to the greatest extent possible; and 3) use tools measuring adherence to determine the success of the planned and implemented menu. Menus were blinded by placing similar dishes on the 2 intervention diets but changing recipes. Adherence was monitored using daily food checklists, a real-time dashboard of scores from daily checklists, weigh-backs of containers returned, and 24-h urinary nitrogen recoveries. Proximate analyses of diet composites were used to compare the macronutrient composition of the composite and planned menu. Meeting nutrient intake recommendations while scaling menus for individual energy intake amounts and food portions was most challenging for vitamins D and E, the sodium-to-potassium ratio, dietary fiber, and fatty acid composition. Dietary adherence for provided foods was >95%, with no differences between groups. Urinary nitrogen recoveries were ∼80% relative to nitrogen intake and not different between groups. Composite proximate analysis matched the plan for dietary fat, protein, and carbohydrates. Dietary fiber was ∼2.5 g higher in the TAD composite compared with the planned menu, but ∼7.4 g lower than the DGA composite. Both DGA and TAD diets were acceptable to most participants. This conclusion was supported by self-reported consumption, quantitative weigh-backs of provided food, and urinary nitrogen recovery. Dietary adherence measures in controlled-feeding trials would benefit from standard protocols to promote uniformity across studies. The trial is registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT02298725.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Dairy Council (58-2032-4-024)
- Campbell Soup Company
- USDA Agricultural Research Service (CRIS 2032-51530-022-00D, CRIS 2032-51530-025-00D)
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Blood Pressure Differences Associated With Optimal Macronutrient Intake Trial for Heart Health (OMNIHEART)–Like Diet Compared With a Typical American DietHypertension, 2014
- Effect of the Mediterranean diet on blood pressure in the PREDIMED trial: results from a randomized controlled trialBMC Medicine, 2013
- Sex differences in the impact of the Mediterranean diet on cardiovascular risk profileBritish Journal of Nutrition, 2012
- Effect of the Mediterranean diet with and without weight loss on cardiovascular risk factors in men with the metabolic syndromeNutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases, 2011
- Dietary Adherence to Long‐Term Controlled Feeding in a Calorie‐Restriction Study in Overweight Men and WomenNutrition in Clinical Practice, 2011
- Dietary adherence and weight loss success among overweight women: results from the A TO Z weight loss studyInternational Journal of Obesity, 2008
- Dietary Adherence in Well-Controlled Feeding StudiesJournal of the American Dietetic Association, 2005
- An overview of methodologies, proficiencies, and training resources for controlled feeding studiesJournal of the American Dietetic Association, 2003
- Effects of Comprehensive Lifestyle Modification on Blood Pressure ControlJAMA, 2003
- Dietary Adherence in the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension TrialJournal of the American Dietetic Association, 1999