Making the Undoable Doable
- 1 December 2005
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The American Review of Public Administration
- Vol. 35 (4), 327-349
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0275074005278511
Abstract
This article interprets Stanley Milgram's laboratory experiments on obedience, and their significance in understanding the Holocaust and the ways by which governmental systems enable people to do things they would otherwise find undoable. Milgram tended to conflate “proximity”—between participants and learners—and sensory perception, and overlooked the difference between physical and emotional distance. Neither Milgram nor his commentators have fully recognized the importance of the shock generator in these experiments. Milgram's paradigm shows why the Nazis' search for increasingly “productive” killing means, which minimized levels of sensory perception among immediate perpetrators, was a necessary (but not a sufficient) condition of the Holocaust. Milgram's key concept of “the agentic state” is reinterpreted as an act of moral choice, rather than as a psychological state of mind. An understanding of the conditional nature of legal-rational (bureaucratic) authority is essential if ways are to be found of resolving “the paradox of modernity.”Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- WEHRMACHT, EINSATZGRUPPEN,SOVIET POWS AND ANTI-BOLSHEVISM IN THE EMERGENCE OF THE FINAL SOLUTIONPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2010
- Unmasking Administrative EvilPublished by SAGE Publications ,1998
- The Ordinary Quality of Resistance: From Milgram's Laboratory to the Village of Le ChambonJournal of Social Issues, 1995
- When is “Obedience” Obedience? Conceptual and Historical CommentaryJournal of Social Issues, 1995
- Psychological Perspectives on the Perpetrators of the Holocaust: The Role of Situational Pressures, Personal Dispositions, and Their InteractionsHolocaust and Genocide Studies, 1993
- The Moral SenseAmerican Political Science Review, 1993
- KOMMANDOSTAB REICHSFŪHRER-SS: HIMMLER'S PERSONAL MURDER BRIGADES IN 1941Holocaust and Genocide Studies, 1986
- Beyond ‘The Banality of Evil’British Journal of Political Science, 1980
- BureaucracyPublished by Bloomsbury Academic ,1970
- Behavioral Study of obedience.The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1963