Mars and Venus in Action? The US and EU’s foreign relations strategies in academic discourse
Open Access
- 28 December 2018
- journal article
- Published by Vilnius University Press in Baltic Journal of Political Science
- No. 7-8,p. 27-44
- https://doi.org/10.15388/bjps.2018.7-8.2
Abstract
[full article and abstract in English] This article reviews the existing academic literature that compares and explains the differences between the US and the EU’s external actions. An analytical matrix is devised to group publications by level of analysis (micro-, mid-, and macro) and by theme of comparison criteria. The key findings are that in the macro level of analysis, authors tend to compare the role actors have in international relations before claiming either that the EU is a different kind of power due to its peculiar historical experience, or that the EU is weak due to its complicated structure and lack of military capacities. Furthermore, authors conducting their analyses at the micro level tend to find more similarities between the EU and the US’s external actions than those working at the macro level. The article concludes by making a point in favour of further comparisons as an essential tool to better understand the EU and other actors in international relations.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- The EU, External Actors, and the Arabellions: Much Ado About (Almost) NothingJournal of European Integration, 2014
- Responses to the ‘Arabellions’: The EU in Comparative Perspective — IntroductionJournal of European Integration, 2014
- Cosmetic agreements and the cracks beneath: ideological convergences and divergences in US and EU democracy promotion in civil societyCambridge Review of International Affairs, 2014
- The stability syndrome: US and EU democracy promotion in TunisiaThe Journal of North African Studies, 2009
- The EU as a modest ‘force for good’: the European Neighbourhood PolicyInternational Affairs, 2008
- The Atlantic Alliance Under StressPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,2005
- The European Union as a Global ActorPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2005
- Mapping the Mind Gap: A Comparison of US and European Security StrategiesSecurity Dialogue, 2005
- Which Power? Whose Weakness? On Robert Kagan's Critique of European IdeologyTheory & Event, 2003
- Western Europe's presence in the contemporary international arenaReview of International Studies, 1990