The need for robust critique of arts and health research: Dance‐movement therapy, girls, and depression
Open Access
- 25 May 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 1525 (1), 128-139
- https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.15006
Abstract
We examine a highly cited randomized controlled trial on dance-movement therapy with adolescent girls with mild depression and examine its treatment in 14 evidence reviews and meta-analyses of dance research. We demonstrate substantial limitations in the trial which seriously undermine the conclusions reached regarding the effectiveness of dance movement therapy in reducing depression. We also show that the dance research reviews vary substantially in their treatment of the study. Some reviews provide a positive assessment of the study and take its findings at face value without critical commentary. Others are critical of the study, identifying significant limitations, but showing marked differences in Cochrane Risk of Bias assessments. Drawing on recent criticisms of systematic reviewing and meta-analysis, we consider how reviews can be so variable and discuss what is needed to improve the quality of primary studies, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses in the field of creative arts and health.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploratory randomized controlled trial evaluating the impact of a waiting list control designBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2013
- Dance movement therapy for depressionPublished by Wiley ,2012
- Is meta-analysis the platinum standard of evidence?Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 2011
- The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trialsBMJ, 2011
- Effect of Immunoglobulin Therapy on the Rate of Infections in Multiple Myeloma Patients Undergoing Autologous Stem Cell Transplantation and or treated with immunomodulatory agentsMediterranean Journal of Hematology and Infectious Diseases, 2010
- A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologiesHealth Information and Libraries Journal, 2009
- ‘Clarity bordering on stupidity’: where’s the quality in systematic review?Journal of Education Policy, 2005
- DANCE MOVEMENT THERAPY IMPROVES EMOTIONAL RESPONSES AND MODULATES NEUROHORMONES IN ADOLESCENTS WITH MILD DEPRESSIONInternational Journal of Neuroscience, 2005
- Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statementJAMA, 1996
- Systematic Reviews: Meta-analysis and its problemsBMJ, 1994