Revealing colonial power relations in early childhood policy making: An autoethnographic story on selective evidence
Open Access
- 19 February 2021
- journal article
- Published by Journal of Childhood, Education and Society in Journal of Childhood, Education & Society
- Vol. 2 (1), 14-28
- https://doi.org/10.37291/2717638x.20212158
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic exposes uncertainty, instability and glaring inequality that requires urgent global policy decisions. Historically, bureaucrats regard uncertainty as the enemy and look for tested solutions (Stevens, 2011). In contrast, Fielding & Moss (2010) acknowledge an uncertain future and encourage shifting policy making towards the search for possibilities instead of replicating singular solutions. Escobar (2020) advocates for pluriversal politics, with many possibilities created through collective decision-making by autonomous interlinked networks. In this paper, I combine autoethnography with policy analysis drawing on my own experience in South African early childhood policy making. I argue for a fresh decolonial debate about early childhood policy to replace dominant imported evidence-based narratives. I pay attention to power relations and examine, not only the content of evidence, but who has authority to speak (Mignolo, 2007). I introduce the bottom-up appreciative participatory dialogical policy making in the Gauteng Impilo project (1996 - 2000), as one attempt to resist the dominant policy trajectory. Local networks, that can inform policy making and resource allocation though conversation and action, emerged from this experience. This article invites urgent inclusive policy debate that expands choices and can produce cumulative worthwhile change and new learnings to birth a better society.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pluriversal PoliticsPublished by Duke University Press ,2020
- Early Childhood Education and Social Transformation in South AfricaPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2018
- Introduction: Decolonizing AutoethnographyCultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies, 2017
- The pilot evaluation for the National Evaluation System in South Africa – A diagnostic review of early childhood developmentAfrican Evaluation Journal, 2015
- Development of South Africa’s national evaluation policy and system 2011−2014African Evaluation Journal, 2015
- Beyond South Africa’s ‘indigenous knowledge – science’ warsSouth African Journal of Science, 2012
- Radical Education and the Common SchoolPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2010
- INTRODUCTIONCultural Studies, 2007
- Changing regimes: Governmentality and education policy in post-apartheid South AfricaInternational Journal of Educational Development, 2006
- Training for Transformation 1-3Published by Practical Action Publishing ,1984