The lesson learned from COVID-19 and the climate crisis is not to let experts decide on policies: a response to Robert C. Schmidt
Open Access
- 27 November 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences
- Vol. 12 (2), 284-290
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-021-00737-7
Abstract
This is a response to the commentary by Robert C. Schmidt in this journal, in which the author suggests that for specific problems such as climate change or the current pandemic, decisions on policies should be made by scientific experts rather than by politicians. We argue that such ideas, which were brought up in the late 1960s and reconsidered more recently, do not take sufficient account of the nature of science politics, and their interaction. Furthermore, problem structures and resulting challenges for science and politics are not similar, but essentially different between climate change and the pandemic. Therefore, different solutions to the problems are required. There is a need to improve politics’ reliable recourse to scientific evidence in many cases. Yet, giving scientific experts such a strong position in decision-making ignores that most decisions, even if based on the state of scientific evidence (if there is such an uncontroversial state of evidence), ultimately require genuinely political choices about trade-offs of interests and normative issues that neither can nor should be made by scientists. Therefore, putting Schmidt’s proposal into practice would not solve the existing problems but instead create new problems.Keywords
Funding Information
- FernUniversität in Hagen
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- How does science-based policy advice matter in policy making? The RIU model as a framework for analyzing and explaining processes of scientific knowledge transferForest Policy and Economics, 2016
- Science Makes the World Go Round. Successful Scientific Knowledge Transfer for the EnvironmentPublished by Wiley ,2016
- Addressing climate change: Determinants of consumers' willingness to act and to support policy measuresJournal of Environmental Psychology, 2012
- Policy formulation, governance shifts and policy influence: location and content in policy advisory systemsJournal of Public Policy, 2012
- Is it time to drop the ‘knowledge translation’ metaphor? A critical literature reviewJournal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2011
- National Institutions and Global Public Goods: Are Democracies More Cooperative in Climate Change Policy?International Organization, 2009
- Why We Disagree about Climate ChangePublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,2009
- The Two-Communities Theory and Knowledge UtilizationAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1979
- The tragedy of the commons. The population problem has no technical solution; it requires a fundamental extension in morality.1968
- The Tragedy of the CommonsScience, 1968