Twin Studies of Political Behavior: Untenable Assumptions?
- 1 March 2008
- journal article
- comment
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Perspectives on Politics
- Vol. 6 (4), 785-791
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s1537592708081917
Abstract
Using the “classical twin method,” political scientists John Alford, Carolyn Funk, and John Hibbing conclude that political ideologies are significantly influenced by genetics, an assertion that has garnered considerable media attention. Researchers have long used human twins in attempts to assess the degree of genetic influence on various behavioral traits. Today, this methodology has been largely replaced in favor of contemporary molecular genetic techniques, and thus heritability studies have seen a diminishing role in behavioral genetic research of the twenty-first century. One important reason the twin method has been superseded is that it depends upon several questionable assumptions, the most significant of which is known as the equal environments assumption. Alford, Funk, and Hibbing argue that this crucial assumption, and thus their conclusion, holds up under empirical scrutiny. They point to several studies in support of this assumption. Here, we review the evidence presented and conclude that these attempts to test the equal environments assumption are weak, suffering significant methodological and inherent design flaws. Furthermore, much of the empirical evidence provided by these studies actually argues that, contrary to the interpretation, trait-relevant equal environments assumptions have been violated. We conclude that the equal environments assumption remains untenable, and as such, twin studies are an insufficient method for drawing meaningful conclusions regarding complex human behavior.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond Liberals and Conservatives to Political Genotypes and PhenotypesPerspectives on Politics, 2008
- Durable effects of concentrated disadvantage on verbal ability among African-American childrenProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2008
- Genetic Factors in Physical Activity and the Equal Environment Assumption – the Swedish Young Male Twins StudyBehavior Genetics, 2006
- Chorion type as a possible influence on the results and interpretation of twin study dataTwin Research, 1999
- A test of the equal-environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illnessBehavior Genetics, 1993
- IQ and HeredityScience, 1991
- Sources of Human Psychological Differences: The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared ApartScience, 1990
- Twins: a test of the equal environments assumptionActa Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 1990
- Twin method: Defense of a critical assumptionBehavior Genetics, 1979
- Resemblance in appearance and the equal environments assumption in twin studies of personality traitsBehavior Genetics, 1976