“Asians Are Good at Math” Is Not a Compliment: STEM Success as a Threat to Personhood
- 1 December 2019
- journal article
- Published by Harvard Education Publishing Group in Harvard Educational Review
- Vol. 89 (4), 661-686
- https://doi.org/10.17763/1943-5045-89.4.661
Abstract
In this conceptual article, Niral Shah critically analyzes how the narrative that “Asians are good at math” positions Asian people as racial subjects. Despite being false, the “Asians are good at math” narrative is prominent in STEM education and is also familiar to the general public. To analyze the narrative's discursive impact on Asian personhood, Shah uses poststructural race theory and Mills's notion of the racial contract, focusing on the interaction between discourses of STEM and discourses of race. Rather than a harmless compliment, Shah argues that the type of mathematical success implied in the narrative dehumanizes Asian people and perpetuates White supremacy, and calls for racial equity and justice work in STEM education to account for ontological questions of personhood alongside traditional concerns about academic content learning and economic access to STEM careers.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Asian American and Pacific Islander StudentsEducational Researcher, 2011
- Chinese Number Words, Culture, and Mathematics LearningReview of Educational Research, 2010
- Constructions of mathematicians in popular culture and learners’ narratives: a study of mathematical and non‐mathematical subjectivitiesCambridge Journal of Education, 2010
- Additional complexities: social class, ethnicity, generation, and gender in Asian American student experiencesRace Ethnicity and Education, 2006
- Disorienting race and education: changing paradigms on the schooling of Asian Americans and Pacific IslandersRace Ethnicity and Education, 2006
- Stereotyping Asian Americans: The Dialectic of the Model Minority and the Yellow PerilHoward Journal of Communications, 2005
- A Foucauldian Gaze on Gender Research: What Do You Do When Confronted with the Tunnel at the End of the Light?Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 2001
- The Racial Triangulation of Asian AmericansPolitics & Society, 1999
- Critical frames in educational research: Feminist and post‐structural perspectivesTheory Into Practice, 1992
- Asian-American educational achievements: A phenomenon in search of an explanation.American Psychologist, 1990