The Role of Discernment and Modulation in Enacting Occupational Values: How Career Advising Professionals Navigate Tensions with Clients
- 1 February 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Academy of Management in The Academy of Management Journal
- Vol. 66 (1), 276-305
- https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2020.1014
Abstract
Enacting occupational values is vitally important to expert professionals’ solidarity and sense of purpose. Yet, many professionals face audiences in their relational contexts—especially powerful clients—who can hold incongruent values and may threaten professionals’ jurisdictional control. How can experts enact their values without jeopardizing their jurisdictional control amidst clients holding incongruent values? We examine career advisers in undergraduate business schools, whose occupational values often contrasted with values common among their student clients. Through an ethnography of one school’s career advisers, combined with interviews of such advisers throughout the U.S., we find that advisers navigated interactions by discerning student values and accordingly modulating their value-enactment practices through masking, moderating, or magnifying their values. This allowed advisers to uphold their jurisdictional control when facing students exhibiting incongruent values, while enacting their values with students exhibiting unclear or congruent values. We contribute to the relational perspective on occupations and professions by positing how discernment and modulation help experts navigate relational tensions by recognizing and drawing on intra-clientele heterogeneity, unpacking how professionals might not entirely resist or change amidst incongruence but instead pursue a more mixed approach, and highlighting when and how experts mask or moderate rather than overtly enact their values.Keywords
This publication has 111 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Relational Ecology of Identification: How Organizational Identification Emerges When Individuals Hold Divergent ValuesThe Academy of Management Journal, 2014
- What Clients Don't Get about My Profession: A Model of Perceived Role-Based Image DiscrepanciesThe Academy of Management Journal, 2013
- Reconstructing institutional complexity in practice: A relational model of institutional work and complexityHuman Relations, 2013
- Values Work: A Process Study of the Emergence and Performance of Organizational Values PracticesThe Academy of Management Journal, 2013
- How to Stop Harassment: Professional Construction of Legal Compliance in OrganizationsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2007
- Empowerment Redux: Structure, Agency, and the Remaking of Managerial AuthorityAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2006
- Object Lessons: Workplace Artifacts as Representations of Occupational JurisdictionAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2003
- The Sociology of Work and OccupationsAnnual Review of Sociology, 1993
- Dynamics of Professional Control: Internal Coalitions and Crossprofessional BoundariesAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1992
- Status and Status Strain in the ProfessionsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1981