Dialectical Materialisms, Metabolic Rifts and the Climate Crisis: A Lacanian/Hegelian Perspective
- 1 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Guilford Publications in Science & Society
- Vol. 85 (4), 501-526
- https://doi.org/10.1521/siso.2021.85.4.501
Abstract
Metabolic rift theory has been accused of assuming an untenable ontological dualism between nature and society. In response, two of its leading advocates, John Bellamy Foster and Andreas Malm, have tried to argue that the approach is not dualist but rather rigorously realist, nonreductively naturalist, and dialectically materialist. According to Foster and Malm, metabolic rift theory is essential because it enables eco-Marxism to make an analytic distinction between nature and society while nevertheless grasping their complex interrelation. From a Lacanian and Hegelian perspective, Foster and Malm are right to preserve the dialectical distinction between nature and society but their respective accounts of this dialectic are insufficiently materialist. Foster falls into a pre-Marxian contemplative materialism. Malm hesitates between his intended realism and Kantian idealism. For metabolic rift theory to be put on a firmer materialist footing, nature must be thought along Lacanian and Hegelian lines as incomplete, thwarted, or shot through with antagonisms out of which emerge the subject and society. To put this in dialectical terms: ontologically there is only nature, out of which society and the subject emerge as an effect of nature's failure to be fully natural.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ecovillages, Restitution, and the Political-Economic Opportunity Structure: An Urban Case Study in Mitigating the Metabolic RiftCritical Sociology, 2016
- Marxism in the Anthropocene: Dialectical Rifts on the LeftInternational Critical Thought, 2016
- Sustaining without Changing: The Metabolic Rift of Certified Organic FarmingSustainability, 2016
- Marx and the EarthPublished by Brill ,2016
- Transcending the metabolic rift: a theory of crises in the capitalist world-ecologyThe Journal of Peasant Studies, 2011
- Deepening, and repairing, the metabolic riftThe Journal of Peasant Studies, 2010
- Ecological Imperialism and the Global Metabolic RiftInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2009
- The Metabolic Rift and Marine Ecology: An Analysis of the Ocean Crisis Within Capitalist ProductionOrganization & Environment, 2005
- Marx's Theory of Metabolic Rift: Classical Foundations for Environmental SociologyAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1999
- Society's MetabolismJournal of Industrial Ecology, 1998