Comment on “Analyses of Mössbauer Experiments in a Rotating System: Proper and Improper Approaches” [Annals of Physics Volume 418, July 2020, 168191]

Abstract

The notion of classical well localized trajectories of a single photon in Minkowski spacetime does not make any rigorous sense by the well-known existence of a proof that single photons cannot be well localized. This leads to principal difficultness when photodetection probability on relativistic non inertial frame of reference is considered. In order to resolve this tension, we extend canonical Minkowski geometry up to relevant point-free Minkowski geometry [Ann. Physics 423 (2020) 168329]. The photodetection probability density on uniformly rotating frame endrowed with point-free Lorentzian geometry is obtained. The result of S. A. Podosenov et al. [Ann. Physics 413 (2020) 168047] is obtained without any reference to unphysical notion of the classical trajectories of photon. The paper again shows the correctness of the remarkable result of Prof. C. Corda concerning the Mössbauer rotor experiment as new proof of general relativity, which has been awarded by the Gravity Research Foundation. In addition, the paper also shows various very elementary mistakes, misunderstandings and flaws by the self-called “YARK group”, which is a group of fringe researchers who attempts to promote wrong science, in particular, against the relativity theory.