Teach Poiseuille First — A Call for a Paradigm Shift in Fluid Dynamics Education
- 1 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT) in The Physics Teacher
- Vol. 59 (7), 552-555
- https://doi.org/10.1119/10.0006462
Abstract
A classic, life science-themed fluid dynamics scenario is blood flow through a constriction. Physics teachers traditionally ask students if the pressure experienced by the blood in the constriction is greater, lesser, or the same as before the constriction. The conventional approach to resolving this question calls upon the equation of continuity, as well as the Bernoulli equation. Biological systems, however, experience a resistance to flow, and a consequential pressure drop, that is often better described by Poiseuille’s law. Within this apparent conflict, which approach is correct? This paper argues that Poiseuille’s law is the more appropriate choice for most biological examples and encourages a Poiseuille-first approach to teaching fluid dynamics in classes designed for life science majors.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Aerodynamic Lift, Part 2: A Comprehensive Physical ExplanationThe Physics Teacher, 2018
- Flawed Applications of Bernoulli’s PrincipleThe Physics Teacher, 2018
- A Kinesthetic Circulatory System Model for Teaching Fluid DynamicsPublished by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT) ,2015
- Pressure Change in an Arterial ConstrictionThe Physics Teacher, 2015
- Rounding off the cow: Challenges and successes in an interdisciplinary physics course for life science studentsAmerican Journal of Physics, 2012
- Reinventing college physics for biologists: Explicating an epistemological curriculumAmerican Journal of Physics, 2009
- Thinking About BernoulliThe Physics Teacher, 2007
- On combining the Bernoulli and Poiseuille equation—A plea to authors of college physics textsAmerican Journal of Physics, 1989
- The Bernoulli-Poiseuille equationThe Physics Teacher, 1989
- Experiment illustrating Bernoulli’s equation and Hagen–Poiseuille’s lawAmerican Journal of Physics, 1980