Genome Editing 2020: Ethics and Human Rights in Germline Editing in Humans and Gene Drives in Mosquitoes
- 1 May 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Journal of Law & Medicine
- Vol. 46 (2-3), 143-165
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0098858820933492
Abstract
The moon landing, now more than a half century in the past, has turned out to be the culmination of human space travel, rather than its beginning. Genetic engineering, especially applications of CRISPR, now presents the most publicly-discussed engineering challenges—and not just technical, but ethical as well. In this article, I will use the two most controversial genomic engineering applications to help identify the ethics and human rights implications of these research projects. Each of these techniques directly modifies the mechanisms of evolution, threatens to alter our views of ourselves as humans and our planet as our home, and presents novel informed consent and dual use challenges: human genome editing and gene drives in insects. I begin with a discussion of so far disastrously unsuccessful attempts to regulate germline editing in humans, including a summary of the first application of germline genome editing in humans and its aftermath. I then turn to a discussion of setting ethical standards for a genomic technology that has not yet been deployed in nature—gene drives. Finally, I end by suggesting that human rights can and should be directly applicable to defining the ethics of genomic research.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Engineering Values Into Genetic Engineering: A Proposed Analytic Framework for Scientific Social ResponsibilityAmerican Journal of Bioethics, 2015
- Human Medical Experimentation with Extreme Prejudice: Lessons from the Doctors' Trial at NurembergJournal of Anesthesia History, 2015
- Don’t edit the human germ lineNature, 2015
- Informed Consent: The Politics of Intent and Practice in Medical Research EthicsAnnual Review of Anthropology, 2014
- The eradication of smallpox – An overview of the past, present, and futureVaccine, 2011
- Asilomar 1975: DNA modification securedNature, 2008
- Ethics: A Weapon to Counter BioterrorismScience, 2005
- The person, the soul, and genetic engineeringJournal of Medical Ethics, 2004
- Viable offspring derived from fetal and adult mammalian cellsNature, 1997
- Not just autonomy--the principles of American biomedical ethics.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1995