Benthic Foraminiferal Indices and Environmental Quality Assessment of Transitional Waters: A Review of Current Challenges and Future Research Perspectives
Open Access
- 8 July 2021
- Vol. 13 (14), 1898
- https://doi.org/10.3390/w13141898
Abstract
Transitional waters straddle the interface between marine and terrestrial biomes and, among others, include fjords, bays, lagoons, and estuaries. These coastal systems are essential for transport and manufacturing industries and suffer extensive anthropogenic exploitation of their ecosystem services for aquaculture and recreational activities. These activities can have negative effects on the local biota, necessitating investigation and regulation. As a result of this, EcoQS (ecological quality status) assessment has garnered great attention as an essential aspect of governmental bodies’ legislative decision-making process. Assessing EcoQS in transitional water ecosystems is problematic because these systems experience high natural variability and organic enrichment and often lack information about their pre-human impact, baseline, or “pristine” reference conditions, knowledge of which is essential to many commonly used assessment methods. Here, foraminifera can be used as environmental sentinels, providing ecological data such as diversity and sensitivity, which can be used as the basis for EcoQS assessment indices. Fossil shells of foraminifera can also provide a temporal aspect to ecosystem assessment, making it possible to obtain reference conditions from the study site itself. These foraminifera-based indices have been shown to correlate not only with various environmental stressors but also with the most common macrofaunal-based indices currently employed by bodies such as the Water Framework Directive (WFD). In this review, we firstly discuss the development of various foraminifera-based indices and address the challenge of how best to implement these synergistically to understand and regulate human environmental impact, particularly in transitional waters, which have historically suffered disproportionate levels of human impact or are difficult to assess with standard EcoQS methods. Further, we present some case studies to exemplify key issues and discuss potential solutions for those. Such key issues include, for example, the disparate performance of multiple indices applied to the same site and a proper assignment of EcoQS class boundaries (threshold values) for each index. Disparate aptitudes of indices to specific geomorphologic and hydrological regimes can be leveraged via the development of a site characteristics catalogue, which would enable the identification of the most appropriate index to apply, and the integration of multiple indices resulting in more representative EcoQS assessment in heterogenous transitional environments. In addition, the difficulty in assigning threshold values to systems without analogous unimpacted reference sites (a common issue among many transitional waters) can be overcome by recording EcoQS as an ecological quality ratio (EQR). Lastly, we evaluate the current status and future potential of an emerging field, genetic biomonitoring, focusing on how these new techniques can be used to increase the accuracy of EcoQS assessment in transitional systems by supplementing more established morphology-based methods.Keywords
This publication has 146 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the Myths of Indicator Species: Issues and Further Consideration in the Use of Static Concepts for Ecological ApplicationsPLOS ONE, 2013
- Effects of Oil from the 2010 Macondo Well Blowout on Marsh Foraminifera of Mississippi and Louisiana, USAEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2013
- Low levels of agreement among experts using best professional judgment to assess benthic condition in the San Francisco Estuary and DeltaEcological Indicators, 2012
- Comparison of benthic foraminifera and macrofaunal indicators of the impact of oil-based drill mud disposalMarine Pollution Bulletin, 2010
- Second-generation environmental sequencing unmasks marine metazoan biodiversityNature Communications, 2010
- Monitoring strategies for re-establishment of ecological reference conditions: Possibilities and limitationsMarine Pollution Bulletin, 2009
- Natural oligotrophy vs. pollution-induced eutrophy on the SE Mediterranean shallow shelf (Israel): Environmental parameters and benthic foraminiferaMarine Pollution Bulletin, 2009
- Assessment of marine benthic quality change in gradients of disturbance: Comparison of different Scandinavian multi-metric indicesMarine Pollution Bulletin, 2009
- A Global Map of Human Impact on Marine EcosystemsScience, 2008
- Transitional waters: A new approach, semantics or just muddying the waters?Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 2007