Defining the role of facilitated mediation in medical treatment decision-making for critically ill children in the Australian clinical context
- 25 September 2022
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Clinical Ethics
- Vol. 18 (2), 192-204
- https://doi.org/10.1177/14777509221125340
Abstract
In this article, we explore alternative conflict resolution strategies to assist families and clinicians in cases of intractable dissent in paediatric health care decision-making. We focus on the ethical and legal landscape using cases from the Australian jurisdiction in New South Wales, while referencing some global sentinel cases. We highlight a range of alternative means of addressing conflict, including clinical ethics support, and contrast and contextualise facilitative or interest-based mediation, concluding that legal intervention via the courts can be protracted and distressing and should be a ‘last resort’. We acknowledge many might view this as the current status quo, but we go further to recommend strategies optimal for all parties to recognise early signs of conflict and prevent its harmful escalation. While more empirical research is needed, we contend that interest-based mediation may be a valuable adjunctive method of conflict resolution. If judiciously distinguished from and utilised with clinical ethical support, it can be an effective tool to address dissent and its negative sequelae in paediatric healthcare decision-making.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Charlie Gard and the Limits of Best InterestsJAMA Pediatrics, 2017
- Clinical Ethics Support for Healthcare Personnel: An Integrative Literature ReviewHEC Forum, 2017
- Mandatory mediation in Australia’s civil justice systemCommon Law World Review, 2016
- Training paediatric healthcare staff in recognising, understanding and managing conflict with patients and families: findings from a survey on immediate and 6-month impactArchives of Disease in Childhood, 2016
- Recognizing and managing conflict between patients, parents and health professionalsPaediatrics and Child Health, 2016
- The zone of parental discretion: An ethical tool for dealing with disagreement between parents and doctors about medical treatment for a childClinical Ethics, 2015
- Conflict in a paediatric hospital: a prospective mixed-method studyArchives of Disease in Childhood, 2015
- Harm is all you need? Best interests and disputes about parental decision-makingJournal of Medical Ethics, 2015
- Conflict Resolution in the Clinical Setting: A Story Beyond Bioethics MediationThe Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2015
- Mediation: an approach to intractable disputes between parents and paediatriciansArchives of Disease in Childhood, 2011