Exploring Supervisory Feedback Formulation on Academic Writing of Research Proposals and Postgraduates’ Responses to Feedback: A Case Study
Open Access
- 30 April 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sage Open
- Vol. 11 (2)
- https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440211007125
Abstract
Despite the emphasis on effective supervisory feedback formulation on postgraduates’ academic writing, our understanding of effective feedback forms may not be comprehensive without mentoring students’ responses to feedback. Therefore, the current case study explores feedback formulation on research proposal writing and two postgraduates’ responses to feedback in a Malaysian university. Data were collected from written feedback, students’ commenting responses to feedback, their text revisions, and follow-up interviews. The feedback is formulated as directive, referential, and expressive, and it addresses issues related to content, organization, linguistic accuracy, and appropriateness in research proposal writing. The two postgraduates engaged in cognitive (e.g., confusion), metacognitive (e.g., reading feedback), and affective (e.g., appreciating feedback) responses to feedback. They integrated most of the feedback in revising their writing and made additional text revisions. Although this study is primarily qualitative in nature, simple descriptive quantitative measures were applied to the data to determine the prevalence of feedback forms, responding and revision patterns. The study provides useful suggestions for supervisory feedback practices.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Facilitating productive use of feedback in higher educationActive Learning in Higher Education, 2012
- ‘Tell me what to do’ vs. ‘guide me through it’: Feedback experiences of international doctoral studentsActive Learning in Higher Education, 2011
- Managing criticism in Ph.D. supervision: a qualitative case studyStudies in Higher Education, 2007
- An analysis of written feedback on a PhD thesisTeaching in Higher Education, 2007
- The Power of FeedbackReview of Educational Research, 2007
- Feedback on second language students' writingLanguage Teaching, 2006
- On being a Supervisor: The Importance of Feedback and how to give itAustralasian Psychiatry, 2006
- Exploring the Practice of Feedback to StudentsActive Learning in Higher Education, 2003
- Research Training and Supervision DevelopmentStudies in Higher Education, 2002
- Comments on Essays: Do students understand what tutors write?Teaching in Higher Education, 2000