Attributes and generic competencies required of doctors: findings from a participatory concept mapping study
Open Access
- 7 June 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 21 (1), 1-14
- https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-021-06519-9
Abstract
Medical education should ensure graduates are equipped for practice in modern health-care systems. Practicing effectively in complex health-care systems requires contemporary attributes and competencies, complementing core clinical competencies. These need to be made overt and opportunities to develop and practice them provided. This study explicates these attributes and generic competencies using Group Concept Mapping, aiming to inform pre-vocational medical education curriculum development. Group Concept Mapping is a mixed methods consensus building methodology whereby ideas are generated using qualitative techniques, sorted and grouped using hierarchical cluster analysis, and rated to provide further quantitative confirmation of value. Health service providers from varied disciplines (including medicine, nursing, allied health), health profession educators, health managers, and service users contributed to the conceptual model’s development. They responded to the prompt ‘An attribute or non-clinical competency required of doctors for effective practice in modern health-care systems is...’ and grouped the synthesized responses according to similarity. Data were subjected to hierarchical cluster analysis. Junior doctors rated competencies according to importance to their practice and preparedness at graduation. Sixty-seven contributors generated 338 responses which were synthesised into 60 statements. Hierarchical cluster analysis resulted in a conceptual map of seven clusters representing: value-led professionalism; attributes for self-awareness and reflective practice; cognitive capability; active engagement; communication to build and manage relationships; patient-centredness and advocacy; and systems awareness, thinking and contribution. Logic model transformation identified three overarching meta-competencies: leadership and systems thinking; learning and cognitive processes; and interpersonal capability. Ratings indicated that junior doctors believe system-related competencies are less important than other competencies, and they feel less prepared to carry them out. The domains that have been identified highlight the competencies necessary for effective practice for those who work within and use health-care systems. Three overarching domains relate to leadership in systems, learning, and interpersonal competencies. The model is a useful adjunct to broader competencies frameworks because of the focus on generic competencies that are crucial in modern complex adaptive health-care systems. Explicating these will allow future investigation into those that are currently well achieved, and those which are lacking, in differing contexts.This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying multi-level culturally appropriate smoking cessation strategies for Aboriginal health staff: a concept mapping approachHealth Education Research, 2012
- Quality and rigor of the concept mapping methodology: A pooled study analysisEvaluation and Program Planning, 2012
- Testing non‐cognitive attributes in selection centres: how to avoid being reliably wrongMedical Education, 2012
- Concept mapping of diet and physical activity: Uncovering local stakeholders perception in the Quebec City regionSocial Science & Medicine (1982), 2011
- Abraham Flexner and the Era of Medical Education ReformAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Commentary: Understanding the Flexner ReportAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Abraham Flexner of Kentucky, His Report, Medical Education in the United States and Canada, and the Historical Questions Raised by the ReportAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Commentary: The Flexnerian Legacy in the 21st CenturyAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Equity and health policy in Africa: Using concept mapping in Moore (Burkina Faso)BMC Health Services Research, 2008
- Complexity science: Coping with complexity: educating for capabilityBMJ, 2001