The Sin of American Jewish Exceptionalism
- 19 August 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in AJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies
- Vol. 45 (2), 282-301
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0364009421000088
Abstract
In recent years, scholars have offered valuable critiques of American Jewish exceptionalism that reveal the historical inaccuracy of an exceptionalist scholarly framework. However, as this essay explains, untethering Jewish studies scholarship completely from exceptionalism discourse may risk overlooking the prevalence of these beliefs and what they tell us about those who propagated them. Exceptionalism does not need to be historically accurate for it to warrant attention from scholars. Nor must scholars approve of exceptionalism, or deem it a positive, for it to be a worthy subject of study. Scholars may indeed view American Jewish exceptionalism as a fantasy that prevents believers from seeing the reality—in particular the problems—of their situation, but the fact that this fantasy had so many fervent espousers should make it a matter of interest. Examining the trail of American Jewish exceptionalist voices reveals the multiple ways these voices have been deployed.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Catholics, Protestants, and the Violent Birth of European Religious PluralismThe American Historical Review, 2019
- Nathan Glazer’s American Judaism : Evaluating Post–World War II American Jewish ReligionJewish Quarterly Review, 2015
- “To Be a Jew on America’s Terms is Not to Be a Jew at All”: The Jewish Counterculture’s Critique of Middle-Class AffluenceJournal of Jewish Identities, 2015
- Nationalism without a Nation?: On the Invisibility of American Jewish PoliticsJewish Quarterly Review, 2015
- Trayvon Martin: Reflections on the Black and Jewish Struggle for JusticeTikkun, 2014
- One Crisis Behind?: Rethinking Antisemitic Exceptionalism in the United States and GermanyAmerican Jewish History, 2013
- Is America “Different”?: A Critique of American Jewish ExceptionalismAmerican Jewish History, 2011
- Is American Jewry Exceptional?: Comparing Jewish Emancipation in Europe and AmericaAmerican Jewish History, 2010
- Rich, Powerful, and Smart: Jewish Overrepresentation Should Be Explained Instead of Avoided or MystifiedJewish Quarterly Review, 2004
- American Jewish Liberalism Revisited: Two Perspectives Exceptionalism and Jewish LiberalismAmerican Jewish History, 2002