The Game of Science and Puzzles of Paradigm
- 29 June 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 55 (1), 167-180
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s12124-020-09563-y
Abstract
Zagaria, Andó́ and Zennaro (in this issue) have offered that the discipline of psychology is fraught with conceptual chaos and a multiplicity of constructs. They have also assessed psychology to be a soft science, with much potential to be a hard science, should it allow itself to be unified by the principles offered by evolutionary psychology. With this approach, psychology would transition from its pre-paradigmatic to a paradigmatic status. In this commentary, we question their premise, method and conclusion, and finally submit that the preoccupation with paradigm is connected with a positivist view of scientific knowledge production. Psychological constructs are not ostensive in nature and cannot be treated as matter is in the hard sciences. This is neither possible, nor desirable. Additionally, such constructs are located in various theoretical perspectives, necessary to understand their multifaceted nature. We question the proposal of evolutionary psychology as an alternative meta-theory. Psychology is essentially a human endeavor, and we must step out of our need to follow the acultural Euro-American vision of positivist science, and instead build an enterprise that can be plural, contextually sensitive and incorporate the complexity and interdisciplinarity needed to be truly successful at approaching the human condition.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Some reflections on potential abuses of psychology’s knowledge and practicesPsychological Studies, 2009
- Clinical Psychology and Evolutionary Psychology: Toward a DialogueReview of General Psychology, 2002
- Clinical psychology and evolutionary psychology: Toward a dialogue.Review of General Psychology, 2002
- On the Place of Culture in Psychological ScienceInternational Journal of Psychology, 1993
- The mythical revolutions of American psychology.American Psychologist, 1992
- Constructing the Subject: Historical Origins of Psychological ResearchBritish Journal of Educational Studies, 1991
- The social constructionist movement in modern psychology.American Psychologist, 1985
- An Intellectual History of PsychologyThe American Journal of Psychology, 1976
- The Worship of Nature. Volume IThe Classical Weekly, 1929
- The knowing of things together.Psychological Review, 1895